See my initial post for the context. Suffice to say that I will be sharing my entries to the Classic Comics Forum tradition, “Twelve Days of Classic Comics Christmas“. This is a cross-post of my third entry, representing #9 on my list of favorite comic book Crossovers.
10. Superman vs. The Amazing Spider-Man
“The Battle of the Century!”
(DC/Marvel, 1976)
by Gerry Conway, Ross Andru, and Dick Giordano
When the word “crossover” was said, crossovers between DC and Marvel immediately sprung to mind. I do love so many of them. And I know exactly what my favorite is, which was set to be #1 on my list, until I read the fine print of this year’s rules and realized I couldn’t have a meeting of their two flagship teams.
So I settled with the classic. The first time Superman meets Spider-Man.
You could tell it was an event. A gigantic comic. So big, that it’s hard to hold. I feel like I need to lay it across my desk to sit on it. But if I do that, the cats try to sit on it. I could shut the door, but then they get angry. Maybe I can sit on the couch with my knee bent to rest it on my leg… look, you try to read this massive comic with two cats who want to sit on your lap and swat at it.
Andru recognizes it’s time for iconic characters to look iconic and draws them as such.
And it’s time for iconic villains. Superman’s archnemesis is pretty universally recognized as Lex Luthor. There is a little more confusion about who Spider-Man’s most iconic villain is. But this comic gets it right: it’s Dr. Octopus.
One less-than-iconic detail that sticks out is the line that Superman fights for “truth, justice, and the Terran way”. It’s an odd phrase. Born out of controversy. The old Superman cartoons had it that Superman fought for “truth and justice”. A good phrase they should have stuck with. But then came the 1950s and McCarthy’s attempts at fascism that led to an epidemic of public displays of patriotism, and the phrase was altered to “truth, justice and the American way”. Out of place for a superhero who should defend all humanity. They seem to be attempting some course-correction here, but they should have just gone back to the original. “Truth and justice” was a good phrase.
It’s also a bit unfortunate that Morgan Edge was Clark’s boss at the time. It would have stood the test of time better if it were Perry White at the bar complaining about his reporters to J. Jonah Jameson. I also wish Peter had met Jimmy, since they’re both photographers. Ah well, can’t win ’em all.
